November 20, 2026
Marianne Stokes via Wikimedia Commons
Carlos Eire on After Disenchantment
The Letters of Robert Frost, Volume 4
What Has Gone Wrong With Fiction in Our Era?
A Norwegian Pop Star Embraces a Medieval Mystic
Form vs. Monsters
Carlos Eire on After Disenchantment
Seventy years ago, in response to a Life magazine editorial that irked her greatly, O’Connor poked the disenchantment of her age in the eye, providing us in the age of artificial intelligence with an object lesson in nonconformism. Mid-century America, she said, lacked a sense of spiritual purpose, a fact that placed her in a tight spot when it came to writing fiction, because the meaning of life for her was “centered in our Redemption by Christ.” Her audience, by contrast, lived in a culture that had been dominated for “the last few centuries” by the “secular belief” that this redemption wasn’t needed at all.
The Letters of Robert Frost, Volume 4
From Dana Gioia in the WSJ:
Beautifully designed, well-illustrated and copiously annotated, “The Letters of Robert Frost” is a model academic edition. It has also been an epic undertaking. This volume, the fourth of a planned five, contains 606 letters written between 1937 and 1946 to friends, family, publishers and an impressive number of collectors. Most are being published for the first time. Despite his injunctions, Frost now lies buried under a great scholarly pyramid of letters and footnotes.
What Has Gone Wrong With Fiction in Our Era?
It’s lost its centrality to the culture. Neil Postman diagnosed the main issue well in 1985. He wrote, “The influence of the printed word in every arena of public discourse was insistent and powerful not merely because of the quantity of printed matter but because of its monopoly.” The issue isn’t about whether books are being published or not. The issue is, in a word, about market share. Print lost the centrality over communication that it had had for several hundred years — first to television, then to short-form online exchange. Fundamentally, there’s no getting that back or putting that genie back in the bottle.
A Norwegian Pop Star Embraces a Medieval Mystic
Some religious artworks are the expressions of broadly believing cultures—think Bach’s Mass in B Minor or the cathedral at Chartres. But today, religious art often has a different character. Rather than giving voice to the dominant outlook, religion becomes a site of resistance to mainstream values. In this way, it can prove attractive to people who normally would not be drawn to dogmatic belief.
Form vs. Monsters
Two recent books by novelists who are Catholic help illustrate the scope of what qualifies as a Catholic novel. Earlier this year, Os Justi Press released The Garden of Perfect Clarity by British writer Roy Peachey, and Word on Fire’s new Luminor imprint republished Peter Kreeft’s 2011 novel An Ocean Full of Angels. In neither novel is the main character Catholic. Peachey’s Acheson, an English boy who grows up in China, has no religion, and Kreeft’s ‘Isa is (and remains) a devout Muslim. Catholicism per se can hardly be said to be the central topic of either novel; neither of the main characters ever sees the inside of a church. What, then, is Catholic about them?